Need a spacious, comfortable and feature-loaded MPV for your family that won't leave you tired even on long drives? So both Kia Carnival and MG M9 are great options. The Carnival comes with traditional diesel power and reliable performance, while the MG M9 delivers a new experience with an electric powertrain, silent ride and futuristic luxury.
Talking about the price (ex-showroom), the Kia Carnival Limousine Plus variant starts from around ₹ 59.42 lakh. MG M9 Presidential Limo price starts at ₹70.90 lakh. The Carnival is more affordable, while the M9 is a bit expensive for the premium EV experience. Both are 7-seater MPVs that are best for large families, chauffeur-driven use or premium transport. Let us know which one is better to buy in terms of design and powertrain?
design details
Kia Carnival comes with a modern and bold look. With 5155 mm length, 1995 mm width, 1775 mm height and 3090 mm wheelbase, it sets the standards for premium MPVs. LED headlamps, dual sunroof and sleek profile make it attractive. Ground clearance is good (180 mm).
Whereas, MG M9 is big and imposing. With 5200 mm length, 2000 mm width, 1800 mm height and 3200 mm wheelbase, it is the largest in the segment. The boxy design, split LED lights, panoramic sunroof and powered sliding doors make it futuristic and road-dominating. Being an EV the front grille is blank. M9 is larger in size, which gives more road presence.
Cabin and Comfort
Both have an atmosphere of luxury, but the M9 is more specialized for backseat passengers. The Carnival features high-quality leatherette, 64-color ambient lighting, ventilated and heated seats. Second row VIP lounge seats provide comfort with power recline and leg rest. Third row is also usable. 12.3 inch touchscreen and digital cluster make it special.
On the other hand, the MG M9 gets presidential seats with 16-way adjustment, massage, ottoman leg rest and ventilation. Dual sunroof, JBL 13-speaker sound system, rear entertainment screens and more space (3200mm wheelbase) make it special. There is massage function in both front and rear rows. The interior is more luxurious and EV-quiet. The M9 seems better suited for chauffeur-driven use.
Features and safety
The Carnival has 12.3-inch dual screens, wireless charging, Kia Connect, powered tailgate, 360° camera, heads-up display, multiple USB ports and good AC. MG M9 has level-2 ADAS, rear touchscreens, V2L/V2V, wireless charging, panoramic view, PM2.5 filter, memory seats and i-SMART connected tech. The M9 is slightly ahead in features, especially in backseat entertainment.
Talking about safety, Carnival has 8 airbags, level-2 ADAS (Adaptive Cruise, Lane Keep, Blind Spot etc.), 360° camera, TPMS, ESC and good structure. The MG M9 can also be bought with 7 airbags, level-2 ADAS, 360° camera, 5-star Euro NCAP rating (expected/similar), ESC, TPMS and high-strength steel body. Both are safe, Carnival has one more airbag.
Powertrain details
Kia Carnival has a 2.2 liter turbo diesel (190 bhp, 441 Nm) engine, which comes with 8-speed automatic and FWD options. Its ARAI claimed mileage is 14.85 kmpl. The torquey engine is perfect for loaded drives and highways. MG M9 has a 90 kWh battery and single motor (242-245 bhp, 350 Nm). Its claimed range with FWD option is 548 KM (MIDC).
Summary: If you want diesel range and value, choose the Kia Carnival. If you want EV luxury, silence and big space then MG M9 is better. Which car you should choose between the two depends on your family use, budget and charging infrastructure. Do take a test drive and compare the two sitting on the rear seat.
The carnival marks the return to India through the SKD or semi-knocked-down route. This means that the country's taxation structure has a big impact on its launch price. Still, the price means this Kia will be out of budget for most mass-market buyers. But for people with big pockets and very specific needs, Carnival is positioned as a solid option barring any real and direct rivals.
We recently reached Bengaluru for a day trip with the latest MPV. Here is our first-drive review of the 2024 Kia Carnival:
How is the Kia Carnival from outside?
Short answer – huge! At 5,155 mm in length, the fourth generation Carnival is absolutely huge. In fact, its dimensions – length, width, height and wheelbase – have increased compared to the previous Carnival in our country. But despite its absolutely epic proportions, it doesn't look ugly from any side or angle.
The Kia Carnival is much more spacious than it appears in the images when seen from the front and with the naked eye. But despite its large proportions, the styling cues are mostly well done to give the MPV an overall visual character.
There is a healthy dose of masculinity on the face which mainly comes from the grandeur of the tiger nose grille in the middle. There are very attractive LED DRL and LED projector headlamp units on either side. The LED fog lamps are placed at the bottom where the skid plate has also been updated.
kia carnival dimensions
carnival limousine
CARNIVAL
total length
5,155
5,115
overall width
1,995
1,985
Overall Height (with roof railing)
1,775
1,755
wheelbase
3,090
3,060
(All figures in mm)
It is from the outside, however, that one truly begins to understand the size of Carnival. At 3,090 mm, this Kia has a longer wheelbase than the Toyota Vellfire, which costs almost twice as much. And the Innova Crysta, priced at almost half the price, looks small in comparison with its wheelbase of 2,750 mm. And styling a massive vehicle is a challenge that Kia has managed remarkably well – the 18-inch diamond-cut alloy wheels, C-pillar garnish, side-sill garnish with matte chrome inserts or here Even the expansive windows and functional roof rails, all add up to pleasing visual aesthetics.
The Kia Carnival will continue to come with sliding doors for the mid-segment. These come with anti-pinch protection feature to ensure that no accidental injuries occur.
At the rear, things are comparatively simple, with the LED tail lamps being the most attractive element here. The rear wiper is hidden under the spoiler and the MPV also comes with LED fog lamps here as well as a matte chrome-plated skid plate. The trunk door can apparently be operated electronically.
The rear profile of the latest Kia Carnival is comparatively simple, with the connected LED lights shining brightest here.
Overall, the Kia Carnival limousine does justice to its name, although finding space for such a large vehicle in typically congested Indian cities can be a time-consuming process.
How is the Kia Carnival in the cabin?
We hardly recommend third row seats in any car available in India. Often a compromise and best only for children or pets, last row seats are practically meant to be an extra bullet point on a car's resume rather than serving a comfort purpose. Scratch that all off for the carnival.
The latest Carnival has a 2+2+3 seat layout with the middle seats acting as the de facto command centre. But the rear seats are quite spacious and good for adults too. There is a lack of under-thigh support, but one can still find enough leg and foot room here for a complaint-free highway ride.
The Kia Carnival has the most spacious third row seats for any vehicle in the Indian car market. Obviously not as comfortable as the two dedicated seats in the middle, however, sitting here won't feel like a compromise either.
However, getting in and out is difficult as Kia missed out on adding a tumble-down function on the middle two seats. This is a big mistake, considering that Karens from the same family have it available at a much lower price. Instead, the Captain seats in the Carnival will be moved forward and out to open up space for entry and exit in the middle. Thankfully, the low height, sliding doors, side step and grab handle make it easy to get in and out. But it's making way for those last row seats, which may not be comfortable for everyone.
However, the middle two seats will be where you – the owner – will always want to be. These captain seats now offer better cushioning than before and can be electronically operated for both recline as well as footrest operation. And although it's not a flatbed, it can be matched to any La-Z-Boy recliner for comfort. Space is once again the biggest strength and even when quite ample room is left for the rear occupants, the middle passengers actually have very generous room to put their legs.
The middle two seats of the Kia Carnival limousine provide both heating and cooling functions. Two armrests on either side of each seat as well as the lightweight contours of the seats and headrests further enhance comfort.
The large windows come with manual shades and three-zone climate control function and the dual sunroof setup gives the cabin quite an upmarket appeal. The position of the front passenger seat can be adjusted by the pillion and there are plenty of Type C charging ports and a 12v charging socket for devices. However, shockingly, there's no foldout tray – even the Carens has this – so you can flip your laptop. And storage space is quite limited, even the bottle holders on all the doors are only big enough for 500ml bottles.
The front part of the Carnival is all about the technology on offer and the two screens – each measuring 12.3 inches – inside a curved casing suit the stature that the MPV wants to portray. The display and response to touch is superb and the feed from the 360-degree camera – essential to managing such a large vehicle – is crisp too. The main infotainment screen packs a mile-long list of features and apps, and will require some learning, although all the information laid out on the driver display is easy to understand. Of course, there's also a big HUD or heads-up display.
The cabin of the Carnival comes in two upholstery colors and the front two seats can be electronically adjusted for position.
The dashboard layout isn't spectacular, but in its simple form, looks quite premium, using soft-touch materials all over. There aren't a lot of physical buttons, but the touch interface once again doubles up and provides controls for both the infotainment functions that are connected to the 12-speaker Bose system as well as the air conditioning.
Inside the Kia Carnival gets a rotary-based drive selector in the center console, buttons to select between drive modes, two cupholders and a set of additional buttons to operate the 360-degree camera and auto-park functionality. There is a pad for wirelessly charging compatible phones while two Type C ports and a 12v charging socket are also placed here.
Overall, the cabin of the Kia Carnival is quite luxurious and extremely spacious. Anything less would have been a detriment to the target audience who would likely be driven by the driver.
How is the Kia Carival?
The Kia Carnival offers a very composed drive and the addition of Level 2 ADAS functions is also a big step forward.
Powering such a big vehicle is no easy task and Kia has used a 2.2-litre diesel motor for this purpose. The unit is mated to an eight-speed automatic gearbox and produces 197 bhp and 440 Nm of torque.
Right off the bat, the Carnival has a car-like drive characteristic with light steering that makes the vehicle relatively easy to drive. Add to this the peppy character of the engine and the peppy gearbox, and the MPV can be unnaturally enjoyable to drive. It's when the Carnival is being pushed that the engine's groan finally reveals that you should probably take it easy. There may be four drive modes – Eco, Normal, Sport and Smart – but the Carnival is best for quiet drives rather than adrenaline-seeking expeditions.
The suspension setup also appears to be soft and the Carnival managed to overcome almost every road obstacle with ease. This is especially notable since the ground clearance is not very high. And yet, even when we drove through rainwater-filled potholes, there was no scratch on the underbody. Of course, there were only two people with two suitcases in the car at that time.
The Carnival experience is best at moderate speeds, but its ratios will take some getting used to in Indian traffic conditions.
The level of refinement also deserves special mention as the control over NVH (noise, vibration and harshness) levels is very good. There is very little outside noise intruding into the cabin and the diesel motor reveals its displeasure when pushed. Middle seat passengers remain snug, but side bolstering on individual seats could have been better to keep passengers in place when lying down.
Carnival again does what it promises, and then some more. It's basically about motivating people, but can also be provocative to a certain extent. The ARAI-certified mileage of less than 15 kilometers per liter sounds good on paper, but in the real world, expect it to max out around 10 kilometers per litre. But who has ever talked about mileage when it comes to Carnival?
Should you buy the new Kia Carnival?
If you're considering the latest Kia Carnival you need to have your priorities straight. If your budget is low, you have a small family, you want an SUV body type or a vehicle that is extremely sporty, then this is clearly not for you.
Instead, the Carnival is for the person who is chauffeur-driven, needs to get things done on the go, wants a luxurious vehicle, takes frequent road trips with the entire family and has the space to accommodate it. There is a big enough garage. Despite being obviously expensive, the Kia Carnival limousine has no direct rivals yet and only in this sense, it can be liked among select customers.
First publication date: 22 October 2024, 11:01 am IST